The new enchantment materials where actually calculated incorrectly by a lot of people. One speculation was that these limited resources would prevent P2W because the bottle neck would be Pure Magic. While this is true to some extent, there is a much more sinister problem. Due to this bottle neck you can't afford to not cron these attempts. You can't afford to delevel the Black Star because you would need to many Pure Magic to restore it each time. This also leaves a disgusting situation. If I want to create Orange tier equipment I'll need to cron the higher enchants. This means I can't gain any fail stacks from this. So where will the fail stacks come from? I already have all the equipment I need. I would need to enchant equipment I don't even need, and completely fail miserably to get the appropriate stacks and try to defeat a ridiculous RNG to succeed the Black Star. So my game mechanics have to be complete garbage to compensate for a few whales trying to P2W their way to the top? This is the best Pearl Abyss has to offer? It's no wonder Final Fantasy now has over 1 million subscribed customers while BDO struggles to remain in 5 digits even with most of them being AFK.