When performing this quest, there is a point where you have to heal your sailor. However, being the nice captain I am, I healed the sailor once I got him and before I accepted this quest. So now I can't proceed. Is there a way to "weaken" the sailor so I can heal him again and continue with the quest line?
OK, resolved. A bit draconian, but sailed ship away from wharf, swam back, and remote collected it. This about kills the sailor and damages the ship, but when I fed him some raisin bread, the quest completed.
Hi there, I'm glad to hear that your issue has been resolved, thank you for sharing how you fixed it with us also