More often than not when people like you come to the forums to insist that the game is dying. It's because you've grown to dislike it and you want to believe it's dying to validate you own feelings. There is still a lot of people playing this game and PA is still coming out with content on a regular bases for players. They've done something akin to dungeons for people who wanted something like dungeons. They made a pvp arena for people who wanted that. This year they're also coming out with new professions & a new region. Now, have they added things no one asked for? yeah. But have they added things that people have asked for? also yeah. Just because the results aren't immediate doesn't mean they aren't listening. I'd agree with you if nothing was being done, but this game is still growing and changing.